Official Luthiers Forum!

Good morning everyone!
On my current project I'm considering using a short scale (24.6) versus the standard 25.5". I have two questions, first does this result in "softer, more comfortable" strings? Can you really feel it? Should I go to mediums? Second, how much volume do you really lose? Should I brace more lightly to try and compensate for the loss of "driving" power? Any and all input will be carefully considered and appreciated......... Thanks, Mikey

_________________
The Biggest Little City, Nevada
www.hammondguitars.com
I love building guitars!

With the shorter scale length it is a bit easier to play for 2 reasons. Less stretch on your left hand for chords and lower string tension. Personally I use light gauge for my 24.9 scale guitars. I think they have plenty of punch and volume. To me, the construction of the box and top design have WAY more to do with volume etc than the scale length and string gauge. IMHO

It looks like I just hit 2000 posts....Brazilian

_________________
Andy Z.
http://www.lazydogguitars.com

Yes. Surprisingly it makes a substantial difference.



That helps.



I wouldn't consider it volume, directly, but timbre. The string has less energy, for sure but more so, the string sounds...floppy, for lack of a better term. Some like it! A kind of twang or bong sound more than the ping of a standard length. A well setup guitar doesn't have that much of a diffference in feel.

John McLaughlin, a personal favorite guitarist, had Wechter set up an acoustic at .009's. VERY light for an acoustic. I believe Wechter did in fact lighten the bracing and thinned the top substantially but it still has the loose sound from the strings.

When the string is first struck the momentum of the attack causes a small and very quick "over pitch" that settles into the intended string pitch for the course of the sustained note of the string. Usually it's considered part of the attack and not considered much. In shorter lengths it is a little more pronounced and I think that is what most people reference when hearing a shorter scale.

One can usually hear this in D tunings on a standard length guitar. It gives the guitar a heavier sound. As for volume, that's determined by how much energy someone can put into the instrument with a pick or finger(..or teeth ). I believe the perception of volume has somewhat to do with it as higher strings and tunings come across as more present than the lower registers.

_________________
Billy Dean Thomas
Covina, CA

"Multi famam, conscientiam, pauci verentur."
(Many fear their reputation, few their conscience)

Put a capo on 1st fret, and retune to 440. Will be excessive compared to what you are proposing for a scale length change, but you will get the feel for the effect.