Official Luthiers Forum!

Owned and operated by Lance Kragenbrink
It is currently Thu Mar 28, 2024 9:56 am


All times are UTC - 5 hours





Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 7 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 6:55 am 
Offline
Walnut
Walnut

Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2020 10:41 am
Posts: 2
Question: What effect do compensated nuts have, and why would you want to compensate both the nut and saddle? In short, why are compensated nuts a thing?

Now for some physics-based background on intonation:
In principle, if strings were negligibly small, there would be no need to compensate them, or it adjust their lengths so that their notes are aligned with the frets. The fundamental frequency they would produce is a simple function of their length, tension, and mass (see http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Waves/string.html.) However, the finite thickness of strings introduces additional effects:

A) Strings are held fixed at both ends of a guitar at the fulcrum of the saddle and nut. Consider the saddle: here, the portion of the string going to the headstock can vibrate, but the portion going the other way is fixed. Now, string wire does not like to bend at acute angles -- it will instead make a radius. The thicker the string, the larger the radius (that's the reason you buy string that's coiled in a loop, and bass strings are larger loops than guitar strings). This radius effectively makes the string stiffer near the saddle and nut, making its effective length for calculating the fundamental frequency slightly shorter. This effect scales with the thickness of the string, i.e. the thicker the string, the shorter its effective vibrational length.

B) There's a secondary effect related to (A), which is that a string typically makes a small angle as it passes over the fulcrum of the saddle toward the headstock. There is some radius to this angle, and the thicker the string, the larger the radius. This contributes to the effect of thicker strings having shorter effective vibrational length.

For (A)-(B), there is an interesting caveat for wound strings vs solid ones, the former having a smaller bend radius compared to a solid one with the same thickness, but in practice the effect on intonation is still present.

C) Finally, there is the effect of intonation of thick vs. thin strings when fretted. The action on thick strings is typically higher because they have larger deflection, so they must be pressed more to touch the fret. For a fixed string length, the higher the action, the higher in pitch the string will sound when fretted. Thus, thick strings will sound sharp relative to thin ones. However, this is a relatively small effect, it probably contributes an order of magnitude less than effects (A)-(B), if at all.

Given this, I don't see why there would be any reason to have a compensated nut over a compensated saddle, or why you would want both compensated. There may be aesthetic or practical reasons, but not physics-based ones. Your thoughts?


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:30 am 
Offline
Contributing Member
Contributing Member
User avatar

Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2011 12:04 am
Posts: 5743
First name: Chris
Last Name: Pile
City: Wichita
State: Kansas
Country: Good old US of A
Focus: Repair
Status: Professional
I'm not convinced compensated nuts are worth the trouble, but if the client wants one... okay. Don't feel the need to put one on any of my stuff.

_________________
"Act your age, not your shoe size" - Prince


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 10:43 am 
Offline
Brazilian Rosewood
Brazilian Rosewood

Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2010 1:46 pm
Posts: 2124
First name: Freeman
Last Name: Keller
Focus: Build
Status: Amateur
There have been several articles in American Lutherie about the theory behind compensated nuts (and possibly moving the first couple of frets). I understand the physics but don't see any compelling reason to do it. I keep thinking that as soon as I fret a note the nut is out of the picture (of course the saddle isn't).



These users thanked the author Freeman for the post: pnin22 (Mon Oct 12, 2020 9:22 am)
Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 6:24 pm 
Offline
Cocobolo
Cocobolo
User avatar

Joined: Tue Mar 14, 2006 12:41 pm
Posts: 316
Location: Trois-Rivieres
First name: Alain
Last Name: Lambert
City: Trois-Rivieres
State: Quebec
Country: Canada
Focus: Build
Status: Amateur
Freeman wrote:
I keep thinking that as soon as I fret a note the nut is out of the picture (of course the saddle isn't).

Partly true as the length of the string is still the length given by the compensated nut!


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 7:39 pm 
Offline
Contributing Member
Contributing Member
User avatar

Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2010 11:42 pm
Posts: 1701
First name: John
Last Name: Parchem
City: Seattle
State: Wa
Zip/Postal Code: 98177
Country: USA
Focus: Build
Status: Amateur
Alain Lambert wrote:
Freeman wrote:
I keep thinking that as soon as I fret a note the nut is out of the picture (of course the saddle isn't).

Partly true as the length of the string is still the length given by the compensated nut!


Ignoring all of the physics and the like... Nut compensation does two things, It helps deal with the difference between a fretted note and an open note. The fretted note first goes to the fret and then up to the saddle, the open note is straight. The second way it helps is to spread the intonation error more evenly across the frets. When doing 12th fret intonation the 12th fret is correct but as you go down the neck toward the nut the intonation error increases. Intonating on both ends allows one to spread the intonation errors evenly across all of the frets.

Most guitars either do not have nut compensation or have a little bit if the nut nut end of the fretboard is cut at the zero fret. People get used to hearing the intonation errors when playing the first few frets. I can see it with a tuner though.

_________________
http://www.Harvestmoonguitars.com



These users thanked the author johnparchem for the post: pnin22 (Mon Oct 12, 2020 9:22 am)
Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Sun Oct 11, 2020 9:18 pm 
Offline
Koa
Koa
User avatar

Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 3:14 am
Posts: 982
Location: Shefford, Québec
First name: Tim
Last Name: Mullin
City: Shefford
State: QC
Zip/Postal Code: J2M 1R5
Country: Canada
Focus: Build
Status: Professional
Nut compensation has been discussed previously on the forum. Perhaps the best treatise on the overall subject is within the Gore/Gilet books — worth the read even if you have no intention of messing with nut compensation.

The objective of any approach to compensation is to minimise the errors in pitch along the string at each fret. If haven’t already done this experiment, it’s worth using a good tuner to establish the error (up or down in cents) for any given guitar at EVERY fret. If you’ve intonated the guitar using the familiar method at the 12th fret, you should of course have no intonation error for that fret, but you will be amazed how variable are the errors at the other frets. You’ll also be amazed at how different those errors are with different string gauges/materials (especially with classical guitars).

Gore describes an approach to intonation (with or without nut compensation) that attempts to minimise overall variance in intonation errors across all frets. I have that programmed into an Excel spreadsheet, but I only use it for classical guitars, where the 12th fret harmonic approach is notoriously bad.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk



These users thanked the author Tim Mullin for the post: pnin22 (Mon Oct 12, 2020 9:22 am)
Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: Mon Oct 12, 2020 3:50 pm 
Offline
Koa
Koa

Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2017 11:09 pm
Posts: 870
Location: Cowichan Valley, BC, Canada
First name: Conor
Last Name: Searl
City: Duncan
State: British Columbia
Zip/Postal Code: V9L 2E5
Country: Canada
Status: Semi-pro
A guitarists technique is worth considering as well. I realized quickly that how I attack the strings with my fretting hand can drastically affect how the guitar registers at any given fret.


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 7 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
phpBB customization services by 2by2host.com